Your pip count is the minimum total number of pips you must roll to bear off every checker. The side with the lower count is ahead. The doubling cube, in a race, is a bet on that lead — and on whose turn it is to roll.
Both rules are approximations, and they are more reliable in long races than in short bear-offs. For the money-game take point they are aiming at, see The Take Point Explained. For the 36 rolls behind the 8 1/6 figure, see the dice roll chart. The same race arithmetic applies at a chouette table, cube by cube. You can check a close money take with the Take Point Calculator, and remaining shot numbers with the Blot Hit Odds tool.
Open the Pip Count Race Calculator to apply the 8-9-12 rule and the Keith Count to any two pip counts, with optional wastage details.
What the pip count is
Multiply the checkers on each point by the point number, then add the products. At the start of the game the position is the same for both sides:
| Point | Checkers | Pips |
|---|---|---|
| 24-point | 2 | 48 |
| 13-point | 5 | 65 |
| 8-point | 3 | 24 |
| 6-point | 5 | 30 |
| Total | 15 | 167 |
Each side starts at 167 pips, because 2 × 24 = 48 + 5 × 13 = 65 + 3 × 8 = 24 + 5 × 6 = 30 = 167.
That 167 is ordinary multiplication, not a tradition. Once someone rolls, the counts diverge, and the race is a comparison of two running totals.
How to count quickly
You do not have to recount every checker from scratch after every roll. Many players keep a running total from 167, subtracting the pips they just played and adding pips created by a hit. Recount from the board when the cube is about to be turned, so a missed hit cannot leave you with a stale number.
When you recount, count in clusters. Five checkers on the 6-point are 30 pips; five on the midpoint are 65; two on the 24-point are 48; three on the 8-point are 24. Those four clusters are the starting position, and the same idea works later: a stack is one product, and nearby stacks can be added as a group.
Accuracy matters more than speed. A count that is off by six pips in a close race is often a different cube decision.
The average roll, and what a roll ahead means
Over the 36 dice rolls, counting doubles as four times the face — 6-6 is 24 pips, not 12 — the total is 294 pips. The average is 294 ÷ 36 = 8 1/6 pips per roll, or about 8.17. That is the same figure derived in the dice roll chart.
A lead of about eight pips is therefore worth roughly one average roll, before you ask whose turn it is. A lead of 16 or 17 pips is about two rolls. Trail by one roll on your turn, and you are closer to even than the raw lead suggests; trail by one roll on the opponent’s turn, and you are further behind. The pip count measures distance. It is not a roll count until you know who is on roll.
The advantage of being on roll
Even when the pip counts are equal, the player whose turn it is is the favorite. Tom Keith, in “Cube Handling in Noncontact Positions” on Backgammon Galore (June 2004), gives a useful approximation: in an even race, the player on roll can expect to win about 60% of the time. He estimates that being on roll is worth about four pips, and that each extra pip is worth about 2.5 percentage points of cubeless winning chance in a close race. Those figures are published approximations, not derived here.
An even race is a favorite for the player on roll, but it is not, by itself, a double.
The 8-9-12 rule
The simplest widely published racing-cube rule of thumb is the 8-9-12 rule, using the raw pip count with no wastage adjustment. As stated by Tom Keith, the player on roll subtracts their own count from the opponent’s, and then:
- Double if that difference is 8% or more of your own count.
- Redouble if it is 9% or more of your own count.
- The opponent should take if the difference is 12% or less of the doubler’s count.
A worked example, using the 80-against-90 position Keith uses to illustrate the rule: your count is 80 and the opponent’s is 90. The difference is 10 pips. Eight percent of 80 is 6.4 pips, so a 10-pip lead is enough to double. Nine percent of 80 is 7.2, so it is also enough to redouble. Twelve percent of 80 is 9.6 pips, and because the opponent trails by 10, which is more than 9.6, the take is short: this is a pass.
A closer window: if you are on roll at 70 pips and the opponent has 76, the lead is 6 pips. Eight percent of 70 is 5.6, nine percent is 6.3, and twelve percent is 8.4. A 6-pip lead is enough to double, not quite enough to redouble, and still a take. The table below lists the three thresholds for a few common counts.
| Your count | Double (8%) | Redouble (9%) | Last take (12%) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 60 | 4.8 | 5.4 | 7.2 |
| 70 | 5.6 | 6.3 | 8.4 |
| 80 | 6.4 | 7.2 | 9.6 |
| 90 | 7.2 | 8.1 | 10.8 |
| 100 | 8 | 9 | 12 |
| 120 | 9.6 | 10.8 | 14.4 |
Thresholds are exact percentages of the on-roll pip count. The 8-9-12 rule is a long-race approximation; it is less reliable when the bear-off is short or the positions are awkward.
The Keith Count
Raw pips miss wastage: pips you cannot use, such as a large number rolled when most of your checkers are already on low points. An extreme case is fifteen checkers on the one-point against three spread checkers on the four-, five-, and six-points. Both sides can have the same pip count, and they are not in the same race.
The Keith Count, also from that 2004 article, adjusts for that wastage. For each side, start with the basic pip count, then:
- Add 2 pips for each checker more than 1 on the one-point.
- Add 1 pip for each checker more than 1 on the two-point.
- Add 1 pip for each checker more than 3 on the three-point.
- Add 1 pip for each empty point among the four-, five-, and six-points.
Then increase the count of the player on roll by one-seventh, rounding down. After that:
- Double if your count is not more than 4 higher than the opponent’s.
- Redouble if your count is not more than 3 higher than the opponent’s.
- The opponent should take if your count is at least 2 higher than theirs; otherwise they should pass.
Lower is still better. The one-seventh add-on is a tax on the player about to roll, so the two counts can be compared after the turn is accounted for. If, after that tax, you are still close or ahead — not more than four pips worse on the adjusted numbers — you have a double. The opponent takes only when your adjusted count is at least two pips worse than theirs.
Here is a fully counted example. You are on roll with one checker on the 1-point, two on the 2-point, and three each on the 3-, 4-, 5-, and 6-points. Your raw count is 59 pips. The Keith adjustment adds 1 pip for the extra checker on the 2-point, and nothing else: the 1-point has only one checker, the 3-point is not over three, and the 4-, 5-, and 6-points are all occupied. That makes 60 before the turn adjustment. One-seventh of 60, rounded down, is 8, so your Keith count is 68.
The opponent has one checker on the 1-point, one on the 2-point, three each on the 3-, 4-, and 5-points, two on the 6-point, and two on the 7-point. The raw count is 65. There is no Keith wastage add-on, so the count stays 65. Your count of 68 is 3 higher than 65. That is not more than 4, and not more than 3, and it is at least 2, so the Keith Count says double, redouble, and take.
On the raw counts, 59 against 65, 8-9-12 agrees: the lead is 6 pips, more than 8% and 9% of 59 (4.72 and 5.31) and less than 12% (7.08), so it is also a double, a redouble, and a take. The two methods will not always agree, especially when one side has a stacked ace-point or a gap in the home board. When they differ, the Keith Count is the one that tried to price that wastage.
Other published formulas — among them Jeff Ward’s count, which Walter Trice discussed in his Boot Camp writing — adjust the raw pips in different ways. They are not the same as the 8-9-12 percentages. The two rules worked here are 8-9-12 on the raw count, and the Keith Count with its own criteria. Learn one well before you mix them.
Long races, short races, and the take point
Treat both rules as approximations for long, relatively smooth races. Once the remaining counts get small, or one side is stacked on low points, the raw lead can lie. A short bear-off is about gaps and unused pips, not only about who is eight percent ahead.
Underneath the rules of thumb is the same expected-value question as in any money game. Passing costs one point. Taking is a bet at doubled stakes on the rest of the race. In a clean race the dead-cube take point is 25%, and cube ownership trims the practical long-race number to about 21–22%, as walked through in the take point article. The 12% pip line is a shortcut toward that neighborhood, not a second theory of the cube. If a race take is close, count carefully, and if you have a winning-chance estimate, check it with the Take Point Calculator.
The point of counting is not to decorate a position with a number. It is to know whether the bet you are being offered — or the bet you are about to offer — is the right side of the equity.
Frequently asked questions
What is a pip count, and why is the starting count 167?
Your pip count is the total distance your checkers still have to travel to bear off. At the start of the game it is 2×24 + 5×13 + 3×8 + 5×6 = 167 for each side. The player with the lower count is ahead in the race.
What does it mean to be a roll ahead?
An average roll moves 8 1/6 pips, or about 8.17. A lead of about eight pips is therefore worth roughly one roll, before you account for whose turn it is. Being on roll is itself an advantage: in an even race, the player to roll wins about 60% of the time, a published approximation from Tom Keith.
What is the 8-9-12 rule?
It is a long-race cube rule of thumb that uses the raw pip count. Subtract your count from the opponent’s. Double if that lead is at least 8% of your own count, redouble if it is at least 9%, and the opponent takes if the lead is no more than 12% of your count. It does not adjust for wastage.
What is the Keith Count?
A wastage-adjusted pip count published by Tom Keith. Start with the raw count, add penalties for extra checkers on the one- and two-points, a crowded three-point, and empty four-, five-, or six-points, then add one-seventh (rounded down) to the player on roll. Double if your adjusted count is not more than 4 higher than the opponent’s, redouble if not more than 3 higher, and the opponent takes if your count is at least 2 higher.
Can I use these rules in a short bear-off?
Use them with caution. Both are approximations, more reliable in long races than in short ones. In a short bear-off, gaps and unused pips matter more than a raw lead, and a small change can flip a take to a pass.
How does this connect to the 25% take point?
In a pure race, gammons are uncommon once both sides have borne in, so the money-game take point sits near the no-gammon line: 25% with a dead cube, and about 21–22% as a live-cube approximation in a long race. The 12% pip-lead take line is a rule of thumb aimed at that same idea. See The Take Point Explained for the expected-value comparison.